Hello dear
Welcome To Lucy's New York Style Pizza
Lucy's New York Style Pizza, located in Idaho Falls, delights locals with its authentic, high-quality cuisine. Known for its generous pizza slices and savory subs, this establishment offers a taste reminiscent of New York's vibrant food scene. Customers rave about the top-notch ingredients and friendly service, making every visit a memorable experience. Highlights include their mouthwatering fire sticks and gluten-free options, which satisfy diverse palates. The warm atmosphere, coupled with unique touches like Ben Franklin-themed boxes, adds charm to the dining experience. If you're after a slice of nostalgia and culinary excellence, Lucy's is the place to be!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Breadsticks
Take&Bake Game Changer
Sm Calzone - CCB
Sm Calzone - Zestpian
About
Lucy's New York Style Pizza
Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza, nestled in the heart of Idaho Falls at 2770 S 25th E. This delightful eatery is more than just a pizzeria; it's a culinary venture that transports you straight to the bustling streets of New York City with every bite. With a commitment to quality and authenticity, Lucy's has quickly become a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike.
At Lucy's, the food is not just a meal — it's an experience steeped in nostalgia and satisfaction. Customers rave about their culinary journey, often recalling fond memories associated with the flavors served here. Valentino Ceci perfectly encapsulated this sentiment, declaring, "This tasted like my childhood." It's clear that Lucy’s takes great care in sourcing ingredients and preparing dishes that resonate with their patrons on a personal level.
One of the trademarks of Lucy's is their remarkable pizza by the slice. The slices are notably large, embodying the true essence of New York style — foldable, cheesy, and bursting with flavor. Michael Herrmann describes it as “the highest quality in all they do,” hinting at the meticulous attention to detail that defines this pizzeria. If you're seeking something extra, their fire sticks appetizer adds a delightful kick, appreciated by loyal visitors like LeeAnna Guyett, who promised that Lucy's never disappoints.
For those with dietary restrictions, Lucy’s gluten-free crust has garnered praise for its taste, proving that everyone can enjoy their delicious offerings. Ima Honestee expressed delight for the Zestpian, calling it a "magical spicy unicorn," while also recommending their heavenly gluten-free brownies for a sweet finish. Each dish, coupled with the friendly atmosphere and attentive staff, makes dining here an absolute joy.
Whether it’s diving into a hearty chicken parmesan sub or exploring the delightful Angus Steak Sub, the menu is replete with options that cater to all palates. Noah Lloyd, after a surprising and delightful first experience, vowed to return, citing the generous portion sizes and exceptional flavor.
If you’re on the hunt for a pizza spot that marries quality ingredients with heartfelt service, Lucy's New York Style Pizza is your destination. Call them at +1 208-523-7777 and prepare to embark on a flavor adventure that celebrates the spirit of New York, right in Idaho Falls. With every dish served, Lucy’s stands out not just as a restaurant, but as a slice of community and flavor that you won’t want to miss!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ First time at Lucy’s and I must say that I’m happy we went in. This tasted like my childhood. I don’t know how you are preparing your food or the ingredients but keep doing what you’re doing. So good. The cherry on top was the Ben Franklin boxes. Hilariously patriotic. Bravo ”
“ We are never disappointed when we come to Lucy's for lunch. Friendly service from start to finish. They use really great quality bread for all of their sandwiches. We're big fans of their fire sticks appetizer, just the right amount of heat and so cheesy! The pizza by the slice deal is amazing, the slices are quite large! We love the chicken parmesan sub, this time I tried the Angus Steak Sub and it was really good too. This is the spot to eat at if you're looking for friendly service, great food, at reasonable prices. ”
“ If your tongue wants to savor the flavor of pure awesomeness - then Lucy's has you covered! The Zestpian was like a magical spicy unicorn prancing on my tongue singing, "Zesty!!". Their gluten free crust is good and their gluten free brownies are even better! Imagine a sweet, gooey, little chocolate square of perfection making your every gluten wish come true - except there is no gluten! It's perfection! Can't wait to return here! The staff was amazing too! Our family kept spilling drinks (this never happens!) And she was so friendly about It! Amazing waitress! Give her a raise or the very least, some free gooey chocolate squares of love! ”
“ Absolutely fantastic. NY style, highest quality in all they do. Only pie in do business with in Idaho Falls! Great customer service and looking forward to see what they come up with next. Thanks Lucy's! ”
“ I had gotten a gift certificate in the mail for a pizza here. My wife and I love to do pizza Fridays so we thought why not try a free pizza here. WE LOVED IT. It was a lot bigger than I thought it was going to be. The taste was very v good and it was a nice good NY style pizza. Definitely want to try different flavors of pizza here. Will come again and recommend this for anyone looking for a good local pizza place. ”
“ This is such a great pizza place! New York style pizza and the slices are huge. It's very affordable and the staff are great. We showed up during the after lunch time and they even gave us complimentary pickles and olives. One pizza was enough for 5 adults and 2 children as well as some cheese sticks. If you are in the Idaho falls area or even Orem UT get a pizza here!! ”
“ Our Family loves Lucy ‘s. Their pizza tastes great. The staff is friendly and they are good to keep the drinks filled up. We have had good service. Lucys is our favorite place for pizza in Idaho Falls. ”
“ Our team popped by for lunch one day. Staff was friendly and the pizza was awesome! We’ll definitely be back often since it’s so close by. ”